Current Research Program:
An enormous variety of marine animals spend the early parts of their lives as specialized planktonic larvae “…in an unregulated state of nature [that] is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.” (Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan). The general goal of my work is to understand (1) why they do so, and (2) the consequences of doing something else.
In many species, adults engage in high-risk sexual behaviour by dumping their gametes into the plankton where (with luck) sperm meets egg to make zygotes. Fertilization rate is often very low, and mortality of offspring is usually very high, so females make very large numbers of tiny, cheap eggs in the hopes that a few will survive. These eggs develop into tiny, vulnerable larvae that often have distinctive adaptations for swimming, feeding, growing, and fending off predators. In some groups, these larvae are so highly specialized for planktonic life that they do not resemble the adult forms at all (for example, the animal at left is a sea urchin, about 1 mm in length, a week or so before metamorphosis into the adult form on the right).These larvae must grow (because initial egg size is much smaller than the size of juvenile stages) and growth is slow (because food particles are often very dilute in the ocean), so the planktonic stage may last weeks or months and result in dispersal and gene flow across large distances (even across ocean basins). In these species, the transition from the larval lifestyle and habitat to the adult involves complex behaviours for selection of a settlement site, followed by a dramatic metamorphosis. In many respects, these life histories are similar to wind-pollinated grasses (with aerial pollen and tiny seeds) and to insects or amphibians (with distinctive larval and adult stages).
But in many other species, often closely related to those with planktonic larvae, adults are much less cavalier about the production & protection of their offspring. These species have some combination of highly derived life history traits, often including:
- Hermaphrodite adults
- Internal fertilization
- Complex gamete exchange (sometimes with mate selection & courtship)
- Large and expensive eggs in small clutches
- Rapid embryonic development without feeding or growth
- Limited larval dispersal
- Brood protection (in egg capsules or the body of the parent)
- Sibling cannibalism within the brood mass
- Direct development from the zygote to the adult form
- Live birth of juveniles
In many respects, these alternative life histories resemble terrestrial vertebrates (with development in egg shells, wombs, or pouches) and animal-pollinated plants (with direct pollen transfer).
My lab group studies the population genetics of reproductive variation, mainly in echinoderms. This work uses knowledge of reproductive traits (either measured by us or by others) set in the context of known phylogenetic relationships and ideas about the direction and pattern of evolutionary changes in modes of reproduction. We’re interested in understanding the population genetic effects of these evolutionary changes in mating system, egg size/number tradeoffs, dispersal ability, and larval morphology.
Recent work in the northwest Atlantic looked at microsatellite and mtDNA population structure in sea urchins, sea stars, and clams in the context of Pleistocene glaciations, range expansion, and hybridization. That research strongly suggests that factors other than simple differences in dispersal ability have a strong effect on population genetic variation in species with widely dispersing planktonic larvae, including:
Mode of male spawning (planktonic sperm versus copulation)
Hybridization with closely related species
Type of population genetic marker analysed
Our new work in the Pacific looks at these correlations between population genetic variation and life history evolution among sea stars in the family Asterinidae. The eastern Pacific species Patiria miniata (at left; and, yes, a 2004 taxonomic revision has returned this species to Patiria again, not Asterina) is the only local species; most species are from the warm waters of the western Indo-Pacific, and the group is especially diverse in Australia. We take advantage of well-known phylogenetic relationships among closely related species or genera of asterinid sea stars (see the diagram for an example of relationships among species with well known life histories). Some species have dioecious adults with broadcast spawning of gametes followed by feeding (red lineages) or nonfeeding (orange) planktonic larval development, but many others have convergently evolved selfing hermaphrodite adults with non-planktonic larval development in egg masses (green) or viviparous brooding with live birth and sibling brood cannibalism (blue).
The new work has several directions: (1) comparison of microsatellite and DNA sequence estimates of inbreeding and population structure among species with different larval forms and mating sytems; (2) analysis of selfing and multiple paternity in species with benthic brooding; (3) study of fertilization kinetics and hybridization in species with planktonic gametes; (4) characterization of genes encoding gamete recognition proteins and their sequence variation within and among species with different mating systems.
We collaborate on this work with researchers in Australia (Maria Byrne at University of Sydney), the US (Rick Grosberg at UC Davis; Rob Toonen at the University of Hawaii, Manoa; and Peter Marko at Clemson University), and the UK (Mike Bruford at Cardiff University).