Spring 1999
Week 11
Exercise No. 9
Problem I:
Determine the argument structure for the following sentences, determine its surface structure, and explain each step: what motivates each step in the following example:
(1) Who does Mary like?
NOTE: Explain each step. Many of you didn't on the last homework.
Problem II
Determine the argument structure for:
(2) What has Bill been doing?
Complete the derivation.
Problem III:
how are the following forms spelled out:
+WH, SOMEBODY, -Nom.
+WH, SOMETHING, +Nom.
+WH, SOMEBODY, +Nom.
Problem IV:
Determine the string derivation of:
WH Pol[+Neg] C[+Irreal] S[+PT] T[+Past] R[-Perf] Asp[-Prog] Vce[-Pass] <PAINT+[-Nom] [NP SOMETHING, WHT, WH\___, [ Nom]] [NP JOHN-[ Nom]]?
You don't have to draw a tree for this; thus rearrange the forms and spell them out; example:
Pol[-Neg] C[-Irreal] S[+PT] T[-Past] R[-Perf] Asp[-Prog] Vce[+Pass] [V SEE, [-Nom] [NP THE MOLE+[PT]] [ Nom] [NP THE CAT [ Nom]]
-->
Pol[-Neg] C[-Irreal] S[+PT]+NP THE MOLE [+Nom] T[-Past] R[-Perf] Asp[-Prog] Vce[+Pass] [V SEE, [-Nom] [NP THE MOLE+[PT] [+Nom]] [P, [-Nom] {BY} ] [NP THE CAT [-Nom]>
.
Problem V:
This is another exercise on problem solving rather than testing what you already know. Determine the argument structure for the following in linear form:
Mary asked Bill if he is coming to class.
Cf. *Mary asked Bill is he coming to class. (No quotes)
You don't have to do a derivation here. Cite the lexical entry for the question operator to account for both matrix clauses and embedded clauses.
![]()
![]()