INTRODUCING VIRTUE ETHICS


Focuses on the behavior of the virtuous person:

Emphasizes the practical dimension of moral deliberation:

Central question
 

Not:  “What are my duties?” or “What makes right acts right?”

Rather: “What kind of a person ought I to be?”


 
THE CONCEPT OF A VIRTUE
 

Two components to virtues (and vices):

1.  Descriptive
2.  Prescriptive


Example 1:  Rudeness

1.  Descriptive:  excessively willful, honest; disregard for social expectations.

2.  Prescriptive: inappropriate; something that warrants disapproval.

Example 2:

1.  Descriptive
 

2.  Prescriptive

Virtues are good in two senses:

1.  Virtues make the person good:
    -- they are admirable in their possessor.

2.  Virtues are good for the person:
    -- they are desirable for their possessor

    --> Solves the “Why Be Moral?” problem

 
THE AQUISITION OF VIRTUE
 

Virtue ethics includes early childhood experience in its theoretical considerations:

“[The] Child is viewed not statically, but as in progress toward full humanity…To lack deliberative skills at a certain stage does not imply the absence of tother cognitive capacities specific to ethical response.  Therefore, virtues, while acquired through habituation, are not entirely divorced from reason, even at the earliest stages of their cultivation” (Nancy Sherman)
 

The cultivation of virtues takes place in stages:

1.  Developing the right habits. (pre-reflective)

2.  Discerning the right circumstances.

3.  Understanding the right reasons. (contemplative)

Having a virtuous character requires all 3
--> Understanding the right reasons, without having developed the right habits, is insufficient.
--> Better to have the habits and then later decide whether to endorse or reject them.
    – else one will waffle between (mere) continence and incontinence (akrasia).