2021, Innovations in Research
The Right to "Vancouverism"
Social Reproduction Placemaking in the Revanchist City
Renters play an important role as policy actors in urban structure. This article calls for a closer examination of renters as policy actors in Kitsilano, Vancouver, a gentrified neighbourhood with a critical housing shortage. With the continual demolition or conversion of affordable housing and the attendant displacement of existing Kitsilano residents, many renters stave off “renoviction” by mobilizing social reproductive labour—sweat equity—to maintain the few unrenovated, circa-1960 apartments that are still affordable. In the context of resilience research, this article recognizes the creative resilience of these renters and aims to collect and integrate their knowledge into Vancouver’s housing policy. Their uncompensated work has slowed or modified the deterioration-redevelopment cycle and preserved communities by reducing displacement. We argue that resilience research could apply advanced urban analytical skills to the creation of a citizen-renter map that addresses renters’ actions, motivations and visions for the future. In the present study, it takes a first step by analyzing relevant census data to confirm a relationship between household income and Vancouver renter/homeowner status.
Vancouver's affordable housing strategy will not gain any data prior to the release of the 2021 Public Use Microdata Files for Kitsilano (where the author has lived for the past 30 years), yet a GeoLive crowdsourced renter eviction map would offer real-time, "boots on the ground" renter eviction data more quickly. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (2019) found that one in 10 renters were forced to move within the last five years, and a GeoLive map could find out the reasons WHY. New York already has an open-sourced eviction map and we want to do a similar project in the first Vancouver gentrified neighbourhood: Kitsilano. This would discover those sweat equity renters of older, circa-1960 apartments staving off evictions through their social reproduction networks by holding onto the last affordable units in a "city of renters." Such work leads to a community association organization combatting the 50-year acute affordability crisis.
“We need to embrace that Vancouver is a ‘city of renters’ with more than half of households living in rentals,” explains Dan Garrison, assistant director for Vancouver’s Department of Planning, Urban Design and Sustainability (Eagland 2020). Indeed, the role played by renters in the city’s real estate economy and society is as crucial as it is, at times, unacknowledged. It is a fact with which I, as a Marxist geographer and a sweat-equity renter in a 1962 apartment, am intimately familiar. I am the “eyes on the street” (Jacobs 1971) in my Kitsilano, Vancouver community. Renters are a large and pivotal part of the Vancouver real estate landscape. Even many owners can only afford their homes by offsetting their mortgage payments with rental income. But the voices of renters as economic and political actors are often marginalized.
About the project
Presentation at Innovations in Research, April 13, 2021
Read Cheryl-lee's book The 6th Eviction: Shining a Light on the Dark Side of Vancouverism, published by BCcampus Open Education via Pressbooks.
RESEARCHER
Cheryl-lee Madden
SFU AFFILIATION
Alumnus, City Program
AREAS OF RESEARCH
Social reproduction, sweat equity, gentrification, housing affordability, rent gap, inequity, inequality, polarization, resilience
Researcher
Cheryl-lee Madden
Cheryl-lee Madden (she/her/hers) has a BA in Human Geography from UBC (2018) and is a leader in social reproduction. She is speaking on "The Right to 'Vancouverism': Social Reproduction Placemaking in the Revanchist City" at the Western Division, Canadian Association of Geographers (WDCAG) and American Association of Geographers (AAG) conferences in spring 2021. Theories of urban location, social areas, neighbourhood and land use change; urban trends and public policy are the themes of her research. As an urban geographer, Cheryl-lee is particularly interested in how people and places, environment and society interact by creating a new map of a sustainable urban Vancouver where all people are able to access higher education and live in the city. Click here to learn more about Cheryl-lee's work.
-
"Your Neighbourhood, In Your Eyes"
Lainey Martin
Undergraduate Student, Faculty of Environment
-
AIRWISE
Sonya Cressman
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Health Sciences
-
Building a New Generation of Equity-Informed Climate Change Evidence
Maya Gislason
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Health Sciences
-
COVID-19 Risks in British Columbia's Neighbourhoods
Valorie Crooks
Professor, Department of Geography
-
Can a city be a school?
Cary Campbell
Faculty of Education
-
Comprehensive Patient-Centred Pain Education (CoPPE) Project
Zahra Ofoghi
Postdoctoral Fellow, Pain Studies Lab
-
Construction of the Gendered Household
Freshta Ahmadzai
Alumnus, Department of Political Science
-
Craft Workers Organize
Benjamin Anderson
Ph.D. Candidate, School of Communication, and Lecturer, Labour Studies Program
-
Equity Is NOW
Nada El Masry and Yara Younis
Refugee Livelihood Lab, RADIUS SFU
-
Gender Vectors
Travers
Professor, Department of Sociology and Anthropology
-
Geographic Distribution of Conversion Therapy in Canada
Amrit Tiwana
Undergraduate Student, Faculty of Health Sciences
-
Health Equity Impact Assessment of Virtual Health Care Services at SFU
Sarah Chae, Aleisha Fernandes, Elisabeth Avery, Serena Bains, Misha'a Khan, and Shabnam Raufi
Student Health Advisory Committee
-
Maintaining Respect and Dignity?
Jake Castro
Alumnus, School of Criminology
-
Project ABC
Xin Tong
Ph.D. Student, School of Interactive Arts and Technology, and Research Associate, Pain Studies Lab
-
Skateboarders and the City
Jenna Aujla
Graduate Student, Urban Studies Program
-
The Dehumanization of Suicide Attempt Survivors by Crisis Line Responders and Laypeople
Spencer Chen
Undergraduate Student, Department of Psychology
-
The Impact of End-Demand Criminalization on Client Behaviour and Sex Worker Health and Safety in the Sex Industry in Metro Vancouver, Canada
Jenn McDermid
Graduate Student, School of Public Policy
-
The Politicization of Human Trafficking Laws
Sydney Brown
Graduate Student, School of Criminology
-
The Right to "Vancouverism"
Cheryl-lee Madden
Alumnus, City Program
-
The creative edge of restorative justice
Brenda Morrison
Director, Centre for Restorative Justice
-
Towards a Regional Strategy on Gender Inclusivity
Moji Adurogbangba and Michelle Green
BC SUPPORT Unit Fraser Centre
-
Transit subsidies, downtown commuting and equity
Peter Hall and Steve Tornes
Urban Studies Program
-
Understanding Precarious Work in BC
Kendra Strauss and Iglika Ivanova
Labour Studies Program and Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (BC Office)
-
University Leadership Pipeline
Genevieve Fuji Johnson
Professor, Department of Political Science
-
Vision Zero Art & Road Safety for Surrey's Newcomer Youth
Hanah Damot, John Vincent Flores, Paola Ardiles, and Nancy Clark
Faculty of Health Sciences
-
What is so-called “conversion therapy” and how can we stop it?
Travis Salway
Assistant Professor, Faculty of Health Sciences