- About CMNS
- Students
- People
- Research
- Centres & Institutes
- Public Safety Deployable
- PSBNs
- Field Tests
- Partners
- Blog
- Images from ICE2015 Phase 3
- ICE2015 Phase 4 Images Added
- Phase 4 and ICE2015 Field Activities Complete!
- Phase 3 Successful and Phase 4 Happening!
- ICE2015 Phase 2 Successful!
- Phase 1 Checkout Tests Complete!
- Deploying!
- Heading up North for ICE2015 prep!
- ICE2015 Site Checkout Complete!
- New video for DUNE2014!
- Lasers, LTE, and mission-critical comms, oh my!
- DUNE2014: Reporting in real time
- DUNE2014: The Voyage Home!
- Phase 4 Complete!
- Phase 3 Images now up!
- Phase 3 Complete!
- Phase 2 Success!
- Return to the School of Communication
- NewsWatch Canada
- Digital Democracies Institute
- Public Safety Deployable
- Labs & Projects
- Applied Communication and Technology Laboratory
- Members
- Projects
- Publications
- Grants
- Visitors
- Events
- Contact
- Links
- News
- Technē
- Universidade Federal de Uberlândia in Brazil
- Revolutionary Horizons?
- Recurring Questions of Technology: A Brief History of Consciousness and Learning, UBC/SFU Summer Institute
- Andrew Feenberg and Norm Friesen: (Re)inventing the Internet: Critical Case Studies
- Tina Sikka: International Award for Excellence
- Neil Narine: Cinema and Social Networks and Globalization, Humanitarian Crises, and Gender
- Read new research on film sound by Neil Narine
- Assessment of Technology in Context Design Lab
- GeNA Lab
- Sonic Research Studio
- The Transnational Culture and Digital Technology Lab
- Public Safety Deployable
- PSBNs
- Field Tests
- Partners
- Blog
- Images from ICE2015 Phase 3
- ICE2015 Phase 4 Images Added
- Phase 4 and ICE2015 Field Activities Complete!
- Phase 3 Successful and Phase 4 Happening!
- ICE2015 Phase 2 Successful!
- Phase 1 Checkout Tests Complete!
- Deploying!
- Heading up North for ICE2015 prep!
- ICE2015 Site Checkout Complete!
- New video for DUNE2014!
- Lasers, LTE, and mission-critical comms, oh my!
- DUNE2014: Reporting in real time
- DUNE2014: The Voyage Home!
- Phase 4 Complete!
- Phase 3 Images now up!
- Phase 3 Complete!
- Phase 2 Success!
- Return to the School of Communication
- NewsWatch Canada
- The Disinformation Project
- Distributed Networks
- Indigenous Classroom Climate Issues (ICCI)
- Cultural Industries in Acute Crisis
- Applied Communication and Technology Laboratory
- Publications
- Books
- The Power of Platforms: Shaping Media and Society
- Discriminating Data Correlation, Neighborhoods, and the New Politics of Recognition
- Transnational Hallyu The Globalization of Korean Digital and Popular Culture
- The Routledge Handbook of Digital Media and Globalization
- Artificial Intelligence in Cultural Production: Critical Perspectives on Digital Platforms
- Awards & grants
- Journal Articles
- Books
- Faculty Research
- Centres & Institutes
- News and Community
- Student Stories
- First Cohort of Communication Research for Social Change MA Students Present their Projects
- Undergraduate student Liam McKay-Argyriou Wins Loran Award for Podcast Development and Community Building
- School of Communication Graduate Researches how TikTok Influences Climate Change Communication
- Meet the First School of Communication Accelerated Master’s Program Graduate
- School of Communication Graduand Discusses how to Step Outside of Your Comfort Zone
- Macy Moreno & Zarena Zaidi on Teaching Children about the Magic of Filmmaking
- Joaquin Suarez and His Drive for Communication Research
- Three Convocating Students Tell Us About Their CMNS Journey
- Genevieve Cheng and Sharing Isn't Caring
- Sureeta Rai Presents Her Research at the FCAT Undergraduate Conference
- Meet Gideone Kremler, Our New CMNS Indigenous Peer Mentor
- Silke Billings: From Student to Full-Time Employee
- Graduating Student Sharlyn Monillas Tells Us About Her Time in CMNS
- Getting to Know Layla Cameron
- Mina Einifar: MA Student, Digital Marketing Expert, and Influencer Activist
- Breanna Blackwell & Undergraduate Research
- Graduate student a top 25 finalist in pretigeous challenge
- Congratulations to our MA and PhD students
- Climate Strike in Vancouver: SFU CMNS Perspective
- A Creative Communicator is on the Horizon | Aliya Dall’Antonia
- Tara Mahoney on inter-generational civic engagement, climate change, and importance of hope
- The Heyang Rural Research Center
- Luke Galvani challenges common stereotypes surrounding disability
- Bernice Mau: How to grow a successful side-hustle as a student
- 2020 Convocation Medal winners
- 2021 FCAT UGC Student Stories
- CMNS Co-op student graduating this fall recognized for her work fostering equity, diversity and inclusion
- CMNS graduate students publish book reviews in the International Journal of Communication
- Communication honours student studies online conspiracy theories, disinformatio
- Communication student Clayton Wong reflects on his co-op journey
- Congratulations to our 2019/20 Major Award Recipients
- Congratulations to our 2020/2021 Major Award Recipients
- Doctoral candidate Stacey Copeland and PhD student Brett Ashleigh are finalists in this year’s SSHRC Storytellers competition
- Embracing the university experience in all forms - Rachel Wong
- Fall 2021 Convocation: Looking Back
- Meet communication undergraduate student Ashran Bharosha
- Gaining experience as an undergraduate: Communication major and SIAT minor expands diverse skill set at SFU
- FCAT UGC Student Stories
- Meet Samad and Lindsay: Convocation Spring 2021 Student Speakers
- PhD candiate Stacey Copeland: Scholarly podcasters are redefining peer-reviewed work
- Memory of migrant abuse fuels SFU Trudeau Scholar’s lifelong fight for human rights
- PhD candidate Belen Febres-Cordero recognized for community engagement work at annual President’s Gala
- PhD student Laya Behbahani is SFU Social Media Newsmaker of the Year
- Stacey Copeland uncovers the historical voices of Canada’s queer media soundscape
- Tri-Agency Scholarships and Fellowships Recipients
- Undergraduate students launch online platform MyCityMyPark project with the City of Vancouver
- Faculty Stories
- Professor Sarah Ganter Awarded Trans-Atlantic Partnership Grant to Research the Meanings of Independence in Journalism
- Reflecting on Professor Stuart Poyntz’ Time as Director of the School of Communication
- School of Communication Professor Milena Droumeva Named School Director
- Getting to Know Your CMNS Faculty: Erique Zhang
- School of Communication professor Wendy Chun named British Academy Fellow
- Sarah Christina Ganzon Racialized and Indigenous Scholars Network Talk
- School of Communication Professor Explores the Rise of Indigenous Media in Canada
- School of Communication Professor Works to Understand the Role of Communication in the Opioid Crisis
- Getting to Know Your CMNS Faculty: Jas Morgan
- Getting to Know Your CMNS Faculty: Sarah Christina Ganzon
- Getting to Know Your CMNS Faculty: Sarah Ganter
- Getting to Know Your CMNS Faculty: Stephanie Dick
- Getting To Know Your CMNS Faculty: Adel Iskandar
- Professors Siyuan Yin, Svitlana Matviyenko, and Karrmen Crey Awarded Insight Development Grants
- Getting To Know Our Faculty: Siyuan Yin
- Wendy Chun and Amy Harris, Keynote Speakers
- A Soundwalk with Milena Droumeva
- Dal Yong Jin Becomes an ICA Fellow
- Protecting Expert Advice for the Public: Promoting Safety and Improved Communications – A Town Hall
- The Medium is the Metaverse: Studying New Media in Virtual Reality
- Peter Anderson: BC floods reveals need for systemic change in emergency management
- Karrmen Crey: Indigenous Epistemologies
- Join the Clubhouse: communication course goes mobile
- Victoria E. Thomas: Seek a research question that sparks your curiosity and challenges your personal ideologies
- Peter Anderson: Fighting fires with better emergency communication
- Andrew Feenberg retires from the School of Communication
- Remembering R. Murray Schafer
- CMNS faculty members receive tri-council grants to support their research
- Cait McKinney receives the 2021 Gertrude J. Robinson Award
- Ellen Balka and UBC researchers take aim at preventing adverse drug events
- Knowledge Mobilizers: Ahmed Al-Rawi
- Enda Brophy receives Confederation of University Faculty Associations of BC Academic of the Year award
- Ahmed Al-Rawi: How did Russian and Iranian trolls’ disinformation influence Canadian politics?
- Martin Laba: What I'm learning about remote teaching
- The Digital Democracies Institute launch the DDI Blog
- Ahmed Al-Rawi co-authors The COVID-19 Vaccine Communication Handbook
- Listening to the city: Livable Soundscapes soundwalk research workshop
- Dal Yong Jin receives the title Distinguished SFU Professor
- Labour challenges of food delivery service workers in Metro Vancouver
- Sun-ha Hong: Big Data's promise to solve society's problems falls short
- Welcoming our new School Chairs
- Peter Chow-White: Social media during a crisis and how we stay connected
- Transforming Discourses, Information Flows, and Power because: BLACK LIVES MATTER!
- Communication professors developing tools to tackle online abuse
- Communications professor Adel Iskandar embraces storytelling and active dialogue
- COVID-19 Research Information
- Yuezhi Zhao receives Canada's highest academic honour
- Siyuan Yin: On the intersectional approach to researching global migration
- Steven Malcic: Envision policy frameworks and user tactics to foster an internet that works for us
- Aleena Chia: Inspired to uncover the infrastructures behind addiction vs engagement in the gaming industry
- Cait McKinney: The transformative history of LGBTQ communities and their communication needs
- Assistant Professors receive SHRCC Grant
- Ellen Balka - implements software to reduce preventable adverse drug events
- Ellen Balka Receives the Paz Buttedahl Career Achievement Award
- Robert Anderson receives the 2018 Chris Dagg Award for International Impact
- SFU CMNS New Website Launch
- Alumni Stories
- School of Communication Graduate Mozhgan Fazli Transfers Research Skillset to Industry
- From the Honour’s Program to Master’s: Alan Röpke Looks Back at his Time as an Undergraduate Student
- Professor Bruce Carruthers Discusses how SFU Experience Shaped his Academic Career
- How Yzobel Biron became a Successful Entrepreneur after Graduation
- Communication alumnus and renowned acoustic ecologist Hildegard Westerkamp receives honorary Doctorate of Fine Arts from SFU
- School of Communication Alumnus Becomes Successful Author while Embracing Working in Industry
- Manisha Singh on Pursuing Her Dream to Becoming a Bestselling Author
- School of Communication Graduand Excels in Academia After Working in Public Relations for 10 Years
- Stefanie Costales on Finding a Job That’s Right For You
- Rumneek Johal: Not Backing Down in the Journalism World
- Prem Gill and Creative BC
- Grace Mavko Takes on the Field of Public Relations
- Naomi Ambrose Introduces the Christmas Snow Woman
- Jennifer Rhyne Takes Her Communication Degree to CBC
- Danielle Leroux and the She Summits Forum
- Anita Huberman, an Alumna Superstar
- Itse Hesse and Black Girl Collective
- Matthew Steinbach: Head Coach, CMNS Alumus, and Venture Prize Winner
- SFU honours three outstanding alumni
- Curiosity and dialogue: Communication alumnus pursues a passionate career of art and education
- Tips from a CMNS Alumnus: Jas Baweja
- Brett Montrose: Communication alumnus to award-winning founder
- CMNS alumnus launches art and essay exhibition
- Jenessa Gladstone: One alumni's journey from SFU to landing roles with Vancouver Whitecaps FC and Arc'teryx
- Shipra Sharma: From International Student Experience to Landing a Marketing Job at Telus
- Manjot Bains - A look at University Writing and Diversity in Media
- Women in Equity Crowdfunding: Elyssia Patterson from Vested.ca
- The Collective Blog
- Barbie: a Surprisingly Feminist Film
- A Quick List of Must-Take Communication Courses
- Social Media as Mirror of Erised
- Handling Anxiety as a Student
- Leading with Quietness: A Note to Working Introverts
- Gaining Experience to Achieve Your Career Goals
- Putting my Passions to Work
- Vanquishing the Social Stigma on Mental Well-Being
- New to SFU? Here Are Three Helpful Tips to Assist You on Your Journey!
- Accessible Online Content Now
- Spill the Tea: Gentrification of Vancouver Chinatown
- Student’s Experience at Careers in Communications
- Finding Balance in Unbalanced Times: Learning and Working Remotely
- Surprising Yourself: How Keeping an Open Mind is One of the Best Things You Can Do as a Young Professional
- Meet Kayli Jamieson: Communication honours student and undergraduate research assistant
- CMNSU: Five Things I’ve Learned at SFU
- CMNSU presents "Evolve Rebooted: The Zoom Series"
- CMNSU: How I Stay Productive While Working and Studying From Home
- Immersing Yourself at SFU
- 5 Tips to get YOU from the classroom desk to an office desk
- You are not an imposter: tips to reframe your thinking
- Becoming familiar with the unfamiliar
- 4 lessons I learned from working at SFU
- FASS 202 & Co-op Experience
- Questions to Ask your Mentors
- Meet Marilyn Brimacombe: CMNS Co-op student shares experience working at FCAT and the Parkinson's Society BC
- Looking to improve your writing skills? Get involved with the CE Online Media Taskforce
- How To Better Manage Your Time While At Work
- Why Joining the CMNSU Was the Best Decision I Made at SFU
- 3 Ways to get Involved at SFU
- 6 Tips You Should Know Before Your Next Virtual Interview
- Paying off your student loans
- 3 Skills I Didn’t Expect to Gain During Co-op:
- Tips and Tricks to Save Money
- Apply Now: Blog Contributors
- Get Involved
- Reflecting on 50 Years of Communication Studies at SFU
- Marking the Passing of Dr. Vincent Mosco
- Guest Lectures
- Student Stories
- Events
- Careers & Opportunities
- Faculty and Staff Login
- Room Booking
Sun-ha Hong: Big Data's promise to solve society's problems falls short
Sun-ha Hong's new book Technologies of Speculation: The Limits of Knowledge in a Data-Driven Society is available now. The introduction and chapter 1 are free to read via the NYU Press. Learn more about the new book in the Q+A below.
Sun-ha Hong
Assistant Professor
Personal Website
What happens to our smart machines when they turn out to be not as smart as they were promised?
How did the book first come about?
In 2013, I was a grad student watching the Snowden leaks play out. It was really an unprecedented moment of public debate and reflection around new technologies and the civic, political repercussions of what we do with these technologies. It suddenly seemed like a serious reckoning of the real world implications of big data was at hand – what happens to real people, their lives and their rights, when we start to turn them into data and judge them by their data.
But there was also a fair amount of skepticism: wouldn’t we just forget about this after a couple of months? After every privacy uproar, every dystopian scandal, we tend to go back and drink deeply from the industry kool-aid. We believe that new technologies are inevitable, and that they’ll optimise everything about our lives: harder, better, faster, stronger. Indeed, even as we were raisig the alarm about data-driven surveillance, we were seeing the exploding popularity of smart machines, self-tracking, and the “Internet of Things”, introducing more and more of this tech into our homes and our own bodies.
So I decided to try connecting the dots. How were these technologies changing what counts as knowledge, as truth, about us? And what happens to our own sense of who we are, and our own sense of the world around us? How are we being required to change who we are in order to become more machine-readable, and to ‘count’ in the right way for the database?
What got you interested in society’s obsession with data?
Across the many different debates we have about new technologies, a lot of the familiar arguments really boils down to what we imagine data is and what we imagine it can do. And a lot of it is a kind of aspirational faith, that the machines will provide objectivity to a society and humanity that seems so woefully lacking in it.
For example, this summer the UK government used a very faulty algorithm to generate students’ university entrance exam scores. This resulted in endless cases of students losing offers, and massive protests ultimately forced a U-turn on the part of the government. There’s an underlying belief there that if you throw algorithms and data at a complex, human problem, it’s going to do provide more accurate and objective results than human decision-making. Or when we hear regular (unsubstantiated) claims that we can use AI to ‘predict’ criminality , it’s riffing off the underlying fantasy that people’s emotional lives, their intentions, their life trajectories, can be reduced into a series of statistical correlations.
The problem is that, inevitably, these assumptions run into a reality that contradicts them, and there arises the violence. Sometimes, it’s just too hard to gather high quality data, leading to inappropriate proxies and unreliable assumptions. In the book, I talk about how difficult it proved to get the kind of data that could precisely predict individual cases of terrorist attack – and so, intelligence agencies would turn to hazy, prejudice-loaded ideas about what constitutes ‘suspicious’ behaviour. At one point you’d even see questions like whether you’ve grown a beard recently, or whether you’ve been subject to assault, as part of an FBI assessment of whether you’re more likely to commit terror attacks. And when you have the immense political pressure, and a broader societal faith, that says you can use data to predict these things…
In their landmark book Objectivity, Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison say that “all epistemology begins in fear” – fear that the world is too complicated to be “threaded by reason”. Perhaps our obsession with data today, or what I call in the book ‘data hunger’, is part of that fear.
What are, if any, misuses of technology and data the general public might not know about?
With the pandemic, we are already seeing an acceleration of data-driven, predictive technologies spreading across workplaces, schools, and other areas of our society. A lot of these tools tend to be very hastily built houses of cards, with a lot of unanswered questions behind the fancy websites – just look at Kiwibot, a startup of automated delivery robots, except it turned out that they were being remotely controlled by outsourced workers in Columbia. But with the pandemic creating a lot of understandable panic and urgency, people are scrambling for solutions, and so we’re seeing a lot of badly built surveillance tech being taken up.
In the book, I talk about ‘control creep’, where technology created for a specific purpose is quickly co-opted by other interests. For example, I examine how Fitbit, the exercise-tracking wristband, originally became popular as part of a broader movement towards self-tracking, where the idea is that you own your data, you control it, and you use it to figure out a better life pattern that suits you as an individual. But over time, Fitbit starts finding new ways to leverage the data it gains about us. Since around 2015, it’s been working with insurance companies, who are really keen to hand out discounted Fitbits and Apple Watches – and then collect that data for their own uses. The potential horizon of use there is clear - I would expect to see such data used to calculate premiums and gate access in the future.
At the end of the day, the majority of what you see branded as an ‘AI’ solution probably doesn’t actually feature any cutting-edge technologies, and the kind of tech we have probably isn’t even appropriate for the particular problem at hand. Princeton computer scientist Arvind Narayanan has a lovely overview of this kind of AI snake oil. Technologies of datafication tend to perform best within tightly prescribed parameters, where they are given very specific tasks to solve. But too often, we are sold the fantastic promise that algorithms and code can be injected into any social problem with the same positive results.
At the end of the day, AI and big data cannot fix chronicly underfunded schools, cure systemic racism at a workplace, or make people wear masks. And when we are led to believe that they can, it is this overreliance on technology that can deepen those problems and inequalities.
Sun-ha Hong's new book Technologies of Speculation: The Limits of Knowledge in a Data-Driven Society is available now. The introduction and chapter 1 are free to read via the NYU Press.
What else can you tell us about the book?
The book essentially asks: what tends to happen when big data and AI’s promises of objectivity and predictivity inevitably fall short? What do intelligence agencies do when the surveillance systems can’t quite predict the next terrorist attack? What happens to our smart machines when they turn out to be not as smart as they were promised? And the key argument of this book is that when the technology falls short, we often make up the gap with speculations, simulations, and fantasies.
So the irony here is that so much of our technologies are predicated on the promise that they’ll replace human decision-making, and all the uncertainty and guesswork and prejudice associated with that, with something that is more objective, more calculative, and therefore, with greater certainty. But it is precisely this overreach that creates the gaps between what our machines do and the problems we want those machines to address. Incomplete and uncertain data get cobbled together to fabricate a sense of reliable ‘predictions’ and objective ‘insights’.
The problem is that such speculations are themselves neither neutral nor coincidental. The book looks at two broad categories of data-driven surveillance: the first is state surveillance, focusing on the Snowden affair and the American government efforts to predict and prevent terror attacks. The second is self-surveillance, or how the growth of smart machines and IoT tech is producing a new ecosystem for data collection that seeps very deeply into our personal lives – the home camera, the voice assistant, the wristband, and so on. And across both of these sites, the book shows how the ‘facts’ about our lives – everything from what counts as suspicious behaviour, to what counts as more optimal in our exercise, our work, our sex lives – is being reconfigured around these technologies and all their flaws.
What is one thing you’d like people to take away from the book?
That when we encounter data-driven technologies, when we see something that purports to be objective data or a predictive analysis, we should ask: what counts?
If predictive policing companies claim to predict high-crime areas through data, and use that to direct police patrols – what do they count as a predictor of crime?
If an online proctoring company promises that they can catch cheating students using indicators of ‘suspicious behaviour’ – what are they counting as suspicious?
This question of ‘what counts’ is inseparable, though, from the follow-up: what counts, and for whom? Because it is no coincidence that these flawed, inaccurate, judgmental technologies of datafication tend to be forced upon the tenants, the workers, the students, the migrants, the poor, the vulnerable.
In the book, we find some folks who find this excess of data to be exciting and empowering. In certain circumstances, it can be an opportunity to know yourself better, and to experiment with yourself into a cool, posthuman future. But for many others, often the most vulnerable among us, to appear correctly in databases is the unhappy obligation on which our lives depend.
Recent blogposts and interviews:
Sun-ha Hong NYU Press blogpost, June 23, 2020
Presentation at the Museum of the Moving Image, (starts: 21:42), August 26, 2020
Interview with Art in America, September 20, 2019